Claims Rejected – Now What?

Dawn Ward • June 4, 2021

As the world becomes less and less predictable, insurance companies are becoming tougher on claims. As a policyholder, you are surely counting on your insurance provider to come through and deliver what is owed to you when the time comes that you need to make a claim. Now, what if your claim ultimately gets rejected?


In this article, we’re going to look at the possible course of action you can take if your insurance claim is rejected.


Step One: Review Your Policy


The first thing you should do before every interaction with your insurer is to review the terms of your
insurance policy. These terms are usually found on the “declarations page” or the “policy summary." 


With this in hand, you should be able to answer all of the important questions. For example, what is covered by your policy? How do you make a successful claim? 


Understanding precisely the agreement that you have made with your insurance company is your priority. Without understanding your entitlements, or the legal implications of how your policy document is phrased, your insurer will immediately be in a stronger position to hand out a rejection notice.


Review your policy thoroughly after your claim is rejected and determine if your insurer has valid grounds not to honor your claim. 


Step Two: Look Over Your Rejection Notice


Similarly, your rejection notice should give you a clue as to what issue your insurance company had taken with your claim. In this letter, the insurer will have highlighted exactly why they have refused you. It may be an apparent issue with coverage, or it could be that they have deemed some of the evidence you provided to be unacceptable for whatever reason. 


The details written in this letter are crucial because they will tell you if the insurance provider caught you out on a technicality. Likewise, if an insurer is trying to get you to accept a lower claim than you feel you’re entitled to, look over their offer with a careful eye, as there may be something you’ve missed when you first read the notice. 


Even better, you could contact a lawyer who specializes in insurance law. They will be best-equipped to interpret the response you got from your insurer.


Step Three: Collect Evidence and Documentation


An important part of appealing any claim is making sure you have sufficient evidence to back up your appeal. This means finding receipts for damaged items, taking photographs of the damage, as well as highlighting the relevant parts of your policy, as needed. 


Some insurers have legal hotlines where you can call and request more information about your specific situation, so check your documents and your insurer’s website to see if this is the case. Doing this may give you a better idea of what kind of evidence and documentation you should present when lobbying for your claim.


Step Four: Contact a Public Adjuster


Many people don’t know that they can use a public adjuster to help them maximize their take-home claim amount. A
public adjuster is a kind of lawyer who can help homeowners assess the full extent of damage to their property before assisting clients during negotiations with their insurers. 


Additionally, a public adjuster can clarify the legal implications of your policy documents and make sure that you, as a policyholder, are aware of your full entitlements under local and state laws. Finally, when push comes to shove, public adjusters can also advise you on appealing your rejected claim successfully.


Get Insurance Adjustment Services Today


If you’re dealing with a claim and are having trouble negotiating for you and your family, contact our team at TSO Public Insurance Adjusters. With over 25 years of experience serving the Philadelphia area, we pride ourselves on being timely and professional when dealing with our clients’ insurance concerns. 


We know that dealing with property damage, theft, or even fire is devastating enough without the compounded hassle of a rejected insurance claim. Luckily, our experienced team of experts has seen every kind of scenario and knows how to get you the best deal from your settlement.


To book our services, call (215) 886-7440 or visit
our website for more information regarding our services.

free insurance claim
By Dawn Ward • August 29, 2026
Philadelphia premiums have jumped 28.9%. Learn how a free insurance claim review can help uncover overlooked damages and potential compensation opportunities.
roof leak damage
By Dawn Ward • August 25, 2026
Learn how flood risk can complicate roof leak damage claims in Philadelphia and discover steps homeowners can take to protect their property and insurance coverage.
property damage
By Dawn Ward • August 22, 2026
Learn what to do after property damage from a break-in or storm in Philadelphia, including documenting losses, securing your property, and starting an insurance claim.
public adjusters
By Dawn Ward • August 18, 2026
With New Jersey insurance premiums up 26% since 2021, discover how public adjusters help homeowners review property damage claims and pursue fair settlements.
property damage insurance claim
By Dawn Ward • August 15, 2026
Learn how roof age can affect property damage insurance claims in Philadelphia, including coverage concerns, claim timelines, and potential non-renewal risks.
property damage
By Dawn Ward • August 11, 2026
Learn how credit-based insurance assessments may affect Philadelphia homeowners and discover what to know when filing a property damage insurance claim.
vandalism insurance claim
By Dawn Ward • August 8, 2026
Learn how to handle a vandalism insurance claim in Philadelphia, understand common denial reasons, and protect your property damage recovery.
Will insurance pay for mold caused by water damage?
By Dawn Ward • August 1, 2026
Will insurance pay for mold caused by water damage? Learn what homeowners insurance covers, common claim denial reasons, and how to protect your claim.
Public adjuster reviewing property damage and insurance claim documents to help a Pennsylvania homeo
By Dawn Ward • July 23, 2026
Learn what a public adjuster in PA does, how they support property insurance claims, and how TSO Adjustment Service helps homeowners.
Stolen household belongings and a damaged entry door illustrating homeowners insurance theft coverag
By Dawn Ward • July 20, 2026
Find out if homeowners insurance covers theft, what belongings may be protected, how to document stolen items, and how TSO Adjustment Service can help.